No true Scotsman

The philosopher Antony Flew illustrated the move in the 1970s with a Scotsman who reads that an Aberdeen man committed a crime and insists "no true Scotsman would do such a thing." Each exception is ruled out by tightening the definition of "true." The result is a claim that can never be proven wrong because it keeps rewriting itself.

  1. noun phrase · /noh TROO SKOTS-man/

    Defending a generalization by redefining its terms to exclude any counterexample.

    Catching it stops a claim from being made unfalsifiable through endless "that doesn’t count" edits.

    "No real scientist doubts this" — and when shown one who does, he replies she isn’t a real scientist: no true Scotsman.

    Like special pleading, it invents an ad hoc exception, but specifically to protect a sweeping generalization.